The 100% Strategy · Answers
What is an active ETF, and is it better than an index ETF?
What is an active ETF?
The European regulator ESMA defines an actively managed UCITS ETF as an ETF whose manager has discretion over the composition of the portfolio, within the stated investment objectives and policies, and which generally tries to outperform an index (ESMA guidelines on ETFs). Germany's BaFin says it more simply: the manager is merely guided by an index and deviates from it in places to try to beat it (BaFin).
It is still a small part of the market. In ESMA's sample, active ETFs held EUR 45.4 billion at the end of 2024, 2% of the assets in EU UCITS ETFs (ESMA market report, 3 March 2026). And 111 active ETFs were listed on Deutsche Börse's Xetra venue in the first nine months of 2025 (Deutsche Börse, 21 October 2025).
Active ETF vs index ETF vs mutual fund: what is the difference?
- Who decides. In an index ETF, the index. In an active ETF and in a classic active fund, a manager. An active ETF should say clearly in its prospectus and marketing that it is actively managed and how it will meet its investment policy (ESMA).
- How you trade. A UCITS ETF, active or not, trades throughout the day on a trading venue with at least one market maker (ESMA). A classic fund is usually bought from and returned to the fund company at a price set once a day.
- What you can see. Not every ETF shows its holdings daily. Luxembourg's regulator CSSF requires UCITS ETFs to publish detailed holdings to all investors at least quarterly, with a time lag of no more than 30 business days (CSSF, 17 February 2026). The prospectus states each fund's policy.
- What risk you carry. With an index ETF, market risk. With anything active, also the risk that the decisions turn out worse than the index.
What types of active ETFs are there?
Issuers use their own labels, so read the investment policy, not only the name. Three broad groups, without any recommendation:
- Enhanced index. The fund stays close to an index and holds a little more of some securities and a little less of others.
- Fully active. The manager picks freely within the fund's rules. Results can differ a lot from the market, in both directions.
- Option strategies. In covered call writing the fund sells call options on shares it holds to earn the option premium; in exchange it gives up gains above the agreed price. Defined outcome ETFs use listed options to offer downside protection with a cap on gains over a set period, typically one year, and deliver that outcome only if you hold from the start of the period to its end (US regulator FINRA, Regulatory Notice 22-08). The payouts are not interest and are not fixed.
How much do active ETFs cost?
According to ESMA, with data to the end of 2024, active ETFs report slightly higher costs than passive ETFs but lower costs than active funds. Over a one-year investment horizon their ongoing costs were 60% higher than those of passive ETFs. For bonds: 0.3% for active bond ETFs, 0.2% for passive bond ETFs and 0.7% for active bond funds that are not ETFs (ESMA). Deutsche Börse puts the average total expense ratio of active ETFs at 0.36% (Deutsche Börse).
The costs of a single ETF are in its key information document (KID), which the provider must give you before you invest and which may not exceed three A4 pages (BaFin).
Do active ETFs beat index ETFs?
The history is short. In ESMA's data, gross and net returns of active ETFs were lower than those of passive ETFs by 14% and 15% over a one-year horizon, and the gap grew over longer horizons. Bonds were the exception: active bond ETFs achieved a net 6.3%, passive bond ETFs 5.7%.
For active funds as a whole the record is longer. Over a ten-year horizon to 2024, actively managed equity UCITS had a net performance of 7.6% a year, against 9.3% for equity ETFs, with ongoing costs of 1.39% and 0.26% a year (ESMA). These are past averages and say nothing certain about a single fund or the future.
Index ETF, active ETF, active fund and the 100% Strategy compared
| Index ETF | Active ETF | Classic active fund | The 100% Strategy | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Fund that tracks an index; trades on an exchange | Fund with a manager; trades on an exchange | Fund with a manager; bought from the fund company | Not a fund or ETF: an automated gold strategy on trading accounts in your own name |
| Costs | In the KID; usually the lowest | In the KID; on average in between (ESMA) | In the KID; usually the highest | USD 6 per cycle per pair |
| Main risk | The market falls | The market falls, and the manager trails the index | The same, with higher costs to earn back | High risk: cycles can lose; results depend on the bonus terms on the accounts |
| Supervision | UCITS rules; no protection against price falls | The same UCITS rules | The fund rules of its home country | Not a deposit; accounts held abroad, outside local deposit protection and the supervision of local regulators such as BaFin |
How do you check an active ETF before you buy?
- Read the KID: objectives, risks, costs and recommended holding period (BaFin).
- Look for "UCITS ETF" in the name. Only funds that meet the ESMA definition should use that identifier (ESMA).
- Find the benchmark and compare results after costs with it over several years, not a few good months.
- Check size and age. A short record proves little.
- Check how holdings are published and, for option funds, what happens when the market rises fast or falls.
- Check the provider in the register of its regulator, in Germany the BaFin company database. Supervision is not a quality seal: BaFin does not check whether a fund is profitable (BaFin).
More: how to choose an investment fund.
Who are active ETFs suitable for?
They can suit an investor who already has a low-cost index core and accepts that an active idea on top may trail the market for years. The basic choice is covered in index fund vs active strategy, example mixes in how to build an investment portfolio.
Tax, for readers in Germany: for equity funds 30% of the income is tax free (section 20 of the Investment Tax Act), and income tax on capital income is 25% (section 32d of the Income Tax Act). Rules differ by country and by person, so ask a local tax adviser.
Where does the 100% Strategy fit?
It is not a fund, not an ETF and not a deposit, but a high-risk automated gold strategy for investors with USD 10,000 or more. The money stays in trading accounts in your own name. Accounts work in pairs of $1,000 each, and each pair needs a second trusted account holder. In each cycle the same gold trade opens on both accounts of a pair, one buy and one sell; the bonus credit on the accounts absorbs the losing side, and profit is moved to a savings account in your name after each round. The running cost is $6 per cycle per pair.
- It is high risk. Cycles can lose, and there is no fixed income.
- Results depend on the bonus terms on the accounts, and those terms can change.
- The accounts are held abroad, outside local deposit protection and outside the supervision of local regulators such as BaFin.
- Past results are no guarantee of future results. It is not available to UK residents.
- Saad Nizar El Soussi's listing with the UAE Capital Market Authority covers financial content. It is not a licence to manage client money and not a licence from any other country's regulator.
Keep it to a smaller part of your money and judge it on its record: since July 2026 every figure in the live record is read from client accounts after each cycle. Read the risks, then join the waiting list; we call you on WhatsApp, usually within a day.
See the record, then apply
The live record is read from client accounts after every cycle. Joining starts with the waiting list and a WhatsApp call.
Less than $10,000? Start with Saad's free community instead: SesTrading on Telegram
Questions people ask
What is an active ETF in simple terms?
An exchange-traded fund where a manager chooses the holdings instead of copying an index, usually to try to beat it.
Are active ETFs better than passive ETFs?
Not as a group. ESMA data to the end of 2024 shows active ETFs with ongoing costs 60% higher than passive ETFs and lower returns over a one-year horizon, although active bond ETFs did better that year.
How much do active ETFs cost?
On average more than index ETFs and less than classic active funds, according to ESMA. Deutsche Börse puts the average total expense ratio at 0.36%.
Are active ETFs safe?
No fund is safe from losses. An active ETF carries market risk plus the risk that the manager does worse than the index.
What is the difference between an active ETF and a mutual fund?
In both a manager picks the holdings. The active ETF trades on an exchange during the day and costs less on average.
Is the 100% Strategy an active ETF?
No. It is a high-risk automated gold strategy from USD 10,000 on accounts in your own name, held abroad.
More answers
- How it works
- Is it legit?
- About & licence
- Results, month by month
- Risks
- Investments with a monthly return
- Where to invest $50k to $100k
- Managed gold trading accounts
- Gold fund or gold strategy?
- Wealth management in Dubai: the alternatives
- Results in 2024
- Results in 2025
- Results in 2026
- How the record is measured
- Monthly income in Saudi Arabia
- Monthly income in the UAE
- Monthly income in Kuwait and Qatar
- How to choose an investment fund
- Gold and monthly income
- How to build a portfolio
- Monthly income investments
- Wealth management fees
- Ways to invest in gold
- Where to invest by amount
- Portfolio management services
- How to invest in a hedge fund
- Automated gold trading compared
- Managed forex accounts in Dubai
- Family office in Dubai
- Investment opportunities in Dubai
- Sukuk and crowdfunding in Saudi Arabia
- Index fund or active strategy?
- Glossary: cycle, pair, bonus credit
- Monthly income in Mexico
- Monthly income in France
- Monthly income in Germany
- Monthly income in Brazil
- Monthly income in Spain
- Monthly income in Pakistan
- Monthly income in India
- Monthly income in Colombia
- Monthly income in Portugal
- Monthly income in Türkiye
- Monthly income in Argentina
- Monthly income in Austria
- Monthly income in Switzerland
- Monthly income in Belgium
- Monthly income in Denmark
- Monthly income in Chile
- Monthly income in Morocco
- Monthly income in Bahrain and Oman
- Monthly income in Egypt
- How to invest $10,000